Marxist interpretation of the french revolution the. The socialistic interpretation has been the most dominant interpretation of the french revolution because it best explains its causes, nature and events. Simon burrows in blackmail, scandal and revolution londons french libellistes, 175892, 2006, demonstrates that all the famous obscene texts about queen ma did exist, but were almost entirely bought up by the french state as the outcome of blackmail operations by their authors and publishers. The french revolution in global perspective on jstor. Interpreting the french revolution tale of two cities by charles dickens 825 words 3 pages. Reflections on the revolution in france summary from. Albert sobouls the french revolution in the history of the contemporary world is an example of a marxist interpretation of the revolution, while colin lucas nobles, bourgeois, and the origins of the french revolution is an example of a revisionist interpretation of the revolution. A watershed event in modern european history, the french revolution began in 1789 and ended in the late 1790s with the ascent of napoleon bonaparte. Edmund burke writes to a young french correspondent, depont, who has asked for his views of the current revolutionary events taking place in france. The storming of the bastille started the hostilities in paris. Austria and other nations such as prussia and england hoped that restoring the monarchy would prevent the spread of the revolution to other countries of.
Interpreting the french revolution by francois furet goodreads. Aug 10, 20 outline the main interpretations of the french revolution uploaded by kerrytom on aug 10, 20. The french revolution is an historical event unlike any other. Incidence of the terror during the french revolution. May 15, 2016 the french revolution taught its contemporaries and continues to teach future generations about their ability to affect incredible political and social transformations when adequately organized. Interpreting the french revolution essay 1759 words bartleby. Alfred cobbans social interpretation of the french revolution is one of the acknowledged classics of postwar historiography. Pdf the french revolution traces the long and short term causes of the french revolution to the october. The french revolution completely changed the social and political structure of france. Paper on marxist and revisionist analysis of french revolution. Hegel wrote, it was worldhistorical, meaning that it changed the history of the entire world the french revolution galvanized and divided populations across.
Pdf the social interpretation of the french revolution by. Outline the main interpretations of the french revolution. But after two centuries, this central event in french history has usually been thought of in much the same terms as it was by its contemporaries. Published as the social interpretation of the french revolution cambridge, i964, p. A political causes the political condition in france was grave due to following political aspects 1 despotic rule of burbo dynasty from 1553 there was depotic rule of.
The social interpretation of the french revolution alfred. If nothing else, i found the title of this book to be amusing, since cobban spends the entire length of the work refuting the idea that the french revolution was a social revolution at all5. The social interpretation of the french revolution is an analysis of the social background of the french revolution by english historian alfred cobban. Years of feudal oppression and fiscal mismanagement contributed to a french society that was ripe for revolt. Interpretations of the french revolution historiographically, the french revolution has been interpreted by three main views. Marxist historian eric hobsbawm defends the orthodox view while the revisionist. Their object is rather to lay, if that be possible, an explanation of it before the english reader. French revolution, revolutionary movement that shook france between 1787 and 1799 and reached its first climax there in 1789hence the conventional term revolution of 1789, denoting the end of the ancien regime in france and serving also to distinguish that event from the later french revolutions of 1830 and 1848. The french revolution erupted in 1789 in response to attempts to raise taxes on citizens to cover debts incurred by the government. This revisionist analysis of the french revolution caused a furore on first publication in 1964, challenging as it did established orthodoxies during the crucial period of the cold war. Gorges lefebvre, for an instance used his marxist interpretation to explain the cause of the revolution. Marxist historian eric hobsbawm defends the orthodox view while the revisionist view is led by alfred cobban of london university. Orthodox and revisionist interpretations of the french revolution.
The french revolution taught its contemporaries and continues to teach future generations about their ability to affect incredible political and social transformations when adequately organized. Split into two distinct parts, furets work savagely critiques the classical or marxist interpretation of the revolution. Students will argue whether the french revolution was the result of one cause or of a combination of causes. The french revolution was the fundamental event of european history in the eighteenth century. What was the significance of the french revolution.
The marxist interpretation of the french revolution. For him, the french revolution was rooted in the bourgeoisie rise burbeck 1819. The views of conservatism, liberalism, and socialism. The french revolution raises many questions not least. Reflections on the revolution in france section 3 summary. During this period, french citizens razed and redesigned their countrys political landscape, uprooting centuries. Alfred cobbans the social interpretation of the french revolution is one of the acknowledged classics of postwar historiography. A look at the different interpretations of the french revolution and how it still divides historians to the orthodox and revisionist interpretations of the french revolution. Burke portrays the revolution society as being too narrow in its interpretation of history and thus too shortsighted regarding the future. Historians efforts to interpret the events of the french revolution are as complex. The older argument that women were enclosed in a private sphere and excluded from politics has given way to a more nuanced and wideranging exploration of diverse groups of women, including prostitutes, parisian market women, crossdressed female soldiers, female schoolteachers, and. Unit1 french revolution of 1789 shivaji university. William doyles oxford history of the french revolution, provides a very accessible overview of the revolution and would be useful for someone new to the field. The traditional interpretation of why the french revolution started is class conflict started the revolution.
A political causes the political condition in france was grave due to following political aspects 1 despotic rule of burbo dynasty. This revisionist analysis of the french revolution caused a furore on first publication in 1964, challenging as it did established orthodoxies. What is the traditional interpretation of why the french. French translation of revolution collins englishfrench. The older argument that women were enclosed in a private sphere and excluded from politics has given way to a more nuanced and wideranging exploration of diverse groups of women, including prostitutes, parisian market women, crossdressed female soldiers, female schoolteachers.
Cambridge core social and population history the social interpretation of the french revolution by alfred cobban. Recent historiography on the french revolution and gender. Burke explains that he does not approve of the french revolution, or the revolution society, which is in contact with frances national assembly and seeks to extend revolutionary principles in england. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. It brought new ideas to europe including liberty and freedom for the commoner as well as the abolishment of slavery and the rights of women. France had invested heavily in the american revolution, and king louis xvi greatly mismanaged the countrys finances. A school of revolution studies was built up at oxford by the late jm thompson, whose robespierre two volumes, oxford, 1935 and the french revolution oxford, 1944 were both strongly influenced though by no means exclusively by albert mathiez. Incidence of the terror during the french revolution a statistical. French revolution simple english wikipedia, the free. A more recent work in the same tradition is professor a goodwins brief but masterly. Pdf the social interpretation of the french revolution.
Interpretations of the french revolution by george rude 1961. Another marxist writer, albert mathiez, was of the notion that the french revolution stemmed from class conflict duvall 14. It put an end to the french monarchy, feudalism, and took political power from the catholic church. After the old government was replaced, differences over the meaning of those principles and the ways they were to be put into practice grew more salient and.
The french revolution was a watershed event in modern european history that began in 1789 and ended in the late 1790s with the ascent of napoleon bonaparte. The correct answer is a class conflict started the revolution. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. It is more than just a topic of intellectual interest. An economic interpretation is an invaluable window into the french revolution from the perspective of someone who was actually there. The economic history of revolutionary france is still a neglected area in studies of the revolution of 1789. The traditional interpretation of why the french revolution started is due to class conflict which led to the revolution. Outline the main interpretations of the french revolution uploaded by kerrytom on aug 10, 20. The french revolution was a revolution in france from 1789 to 1799. The social interpretation of the french revolution by alfred cobban. Free interpretations of the french revolution essay.
The french revolution was an event of great historical significance. The social interpretation of the french revolution by alfred. No one factor was directly responsible for the french revolution. Over 100,000 french translations of english words and phrases.
Reflections on the revisionist interpretation of the french. French revolution historiography can be as contentious as the revolution itself. The classes of people disagreed over many things in france, which eventually led to them fighting over who is going to rule the country. Interpreting french revolution european history after 1450. Its ideas and outcomes shaped not just the development of france but the history of europe. The social interpretation of the french revolution. The social interpretation of the french revolution the wiles. Having the distinction of being so retrograde that the author can presumably be found on the cover, the french revolution.
The french revolution bellocpreface wikisource, the free. In academia, debate rages over two rival interpretations of the french revolution. The rights they champion, if carried to their logical conclusions, would actually serve to undermine the very basis of english liberty and undo much that the radicals presumably wish to maintain. Austria and other nations such as prussia and england hoped that restoring the monarchy would prevent the spread of the revolution to other countries of europe and make their own rule more secure. There are two main interpretations of its causes and consequences. Interpreting the french revolution by francois furet. Interpretations of the french revolution historical association. The result of the french revolution was the end of the monarchy. In the case of the french revolution that tradition is a marxist or jacobin interpretation best represented by quatrevingtneufby georges lefebvre, the classic work of 1939 that was published in the u. Students must use the documents and data sets to support their thesis. Reflections on the revisionist interpretation of the french revolution michel vovelle within the historiographical debate that has marked the bicentennial of the french revolution there is a widely held opinion in both france and abroad that revisionism has triumphed over the traditional or jacobin interpretation of the revolutionary era. Before 1789, france was ruled by the nobles and the catholic church. Because of its significance, the french revolution has been studied by hundreds of historians.
Interpreting the french revolution, francois furets most famous and widely celebrated text, represents an important and fascinating addition to the debate over the nature and significance of the french revolution. Austria was the home of queen marie antoinette and they wanted to put both louis and marie back on the throne. The revolution controversy was a pamphlet war set off by the publication of a discourse on the love of our country, a speech given by richard price to the revolution society on 4 november 1789, supporting the french revolution as he had the american revolution, and saying that patriotism actually centers around loving the people and. The object of these few pages is not to recount once more the history of the revolution. As a result, france was on the brink of bankruptcy and desperate for ways to raise revenue. The following assignment will help you remember key events and figures from the program.
815 890 63 1535 1235 500 574 1588 1122 399 1519 634 1025 572 1585 1304 195 1012 506 952 1545 196 472 344 638 1081 1421 388 1034 1210 26 1469 528 481